SpotCrime Transparency Ranking: June 2017 Update

By
The open crime data landscape is changing for the better. More and more cities are beginning to publish their crime data openly. We are seeing a shift away from data silos and move toward open data feeds and portals across the country.

With advantages of transparency far outranking disadvantages (if any), hundreds of agencies are making their data openly accessible. At this point, it doesn’t make much sense why any police agency still isn’t on board with open data.

The SpotCrime Transparency Ranking has been updated to reflect the changes.

If you have any questions about any of the rankings, or if you’d like to see a city ranked that’s not on the list, please let us know! 


Boston, MA: 0 to 2
They were a 0 in our last update because they upgraded their RMS system, but in the process of upgrading, their public access point to open crime data was kicked offline. When public access to data gets turned off because of an upgrade, we refer to it as ‘upgrading out of transparency’. However, Boston was able to successfully launch a new data portal called Analyze Boston that included a crime data feed!

Hampton, VA: 0 to 2
Hampton has always had a 0 ranking, until about a month ago! We had been trying to get them to open up crime data for a couple of years and recently the department’s attitude toward technology has changed (for the better) and they’ve begun utilizing open crime data to be more transparent with the public.

Las Vegas, NV: 1 to a 2
In the past Las Vegas has been a 1 because they were publishing data (SpotCrime had a feed),, but we couldn’t manage to get them to share the feed with the public and press (or anyone who asked for it) - until now!

Minneapolis, MN: 1 to a 2
Our frustration with Minneapolis has been that even after their roll out of an open data policy and an open data portal, they were only updating crime data about every 6 months while their crime mapping vendor received up to date information. We were connecting and reconnecting with them over a period of about 3 years. It was a big sigh of relief to see they were able to finally automate their feed to the open data portal!

Kansas City, KS: 1 to a 0
We’ve learned that Kansas City, KS has the technical capabilities to be open and transparent with crime data, they’re just choosing not to be transparent with their community. SpotCrime was mapping Kansas City, KS for a couple of years. Last year, Kansas City turned off the public crime data feed to everyone except their proprietary crime mapping vendor. Interestingly, this was around the same time that their neighbor city Kansas City, MO started publishing crime data to an open data portal.

Aurora, CO: 0
We’ve added Aurora, CO to our list not only because of no public access point to crime data, but because of the extra complexity the city uses to respond to FOIA requests. When we submitted a FOIA for crime data, we found that the only way they respond to requests is by saving machine readable data (excel file, csv, file, etc) as pdfs. Then, they place the PDFs onto a CD and then snail mail the CD. We eventually got them to email us the files, but because of the complexity behind requesting the data, we stopped requesting data. Throughout the process, we learned SpotCrime isn’t the only entity to run into FOIA issues in Aurora - the city was printing out spreadsheets onto actual paper and snail mailing it to a PBS reporter.

El Paso, TX: 0
This is another city that, like Aurora, purposefully slows down access to public information. What is most frustrating in El Paso is they were emailing the data for free. But, after a ‘policy change’ they began snail mailing and charging for data. The good news is we are mapping crime from the El Paso County Sheriff.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SpotCrime Weekly Reads: AI, police conduct, transparency

By protector
Image
Police conduct, retired officers back to work, misconduct files released, lack of data stalling cases, association between food insecurity and intimate partner violence, crime victim federal aid drops, crimes against USPS workers, AI in policing, police tech and AI ease workforce woes, WisDOJ sued over police transparency, states that publish current crime data, independent oversight for federal prison system, and more... POLICE CONDUCT N.M. Police Department to Bring Retired Officers Back to Work  (Officer.com) New Louisiana law will criminalize approaching police under certain circumstances  (KGET) Chicago police misconduct files will soon be made public. ‘This is a huge step forward for transparency’  (Chicago Sun Times) A cop gave Fresno man a jaywalking ticket. Then came ‘campaign of hate and revenge’  (Fresno Bee) George Floyd’s murder led to a national reckoning on policing, but efforts have stalled or reversed  (NBC News) L.A.’s dirtiest cop: A mild-mannered traffic officer who
Read more

SpotCrime Weekly Reads: Violent crime, AI tech, transparency

By
Image
Fired cops, police advisory committee, police community relations, traffic stops clogging courts, police discipline records, National Crime Victimization Survey, stranger danger and violent crime, reducing gun crime, stolen guns, rap music used as evidence to convict, AI tool in criminal cases faces legal challenges, AI cameras, drones respond to 911 calls, police transparency in Pittsburgh, police data transparency, dashboards for criminal justice, and more... POLICE CONDUCT The Police Department for Fired Cops  (Illinois Answers Project) New police advisory committee formed after changes from state law  (Fox13Memphis) Using basketball to improve police-community relations and lower gun violence  (The Philadelphia Inquirer) In Memphis, Minor Traffic Stops are Clogging Courts and Draining Resources  (Vera.org) Yonkers PD must hand over police discipline records to civil liberties group, judge rules  (AOL) CRIME RATE National Crime Victimization Survey: Prevalence Estimation Methods  (C
Read more

SpotCrime Weekly Reads: Surveillance, crime rate, prison

By
Image
Naming officers in police misconduct investigations, easing restrictions on marijuana, citizen oversight board, traffic stops, decline in use of force, support for police, drop in crime, National Crime Victimization Survey, expanding surveillance, proactive policing and surveillance, automated license plate readers, crypto money laundering, AI, residents demand more transparency, charging for prison cells, juvenile detention centers, and more... POLICE CONDUCT State supreme court: DA must name officers in police misconduct investigations  (AOL) US poised to ease restrictions on marijuana in historic shift, but it’ll remain controlled substance  (AP News) The Louisiana Town Where a Traffic Stop Can Lead to One Charge After Another  (ProPublica) New citizen oversight board legislation enacted to support police, 'worrisome' to critics  (Herald-Tribune) 21 senior members of DC police to be dismissed — more than half due to ‘serious misconduct’  (WTOP) Despite Increase in Arrests, H
Read more